The ice cream

store

SUBMIT A FLAVOR IDEA!
Please be as detailed as possible! You could even be featured on our website if your flavor is picked for sale!



HOMEMADE ICE CREAM FLAVORS
*FLAVORS DO SWITCH OUT WEEKLY. Only 100 or so flavors will fit in the store at once (including Homemade and Regular) so it is not guaranteed that your favorite will be in stock when you stop in!

African Vanilla- The absolute best vanilla ice cream that we could make. Extremely smooth and flavorful. The special vanilla extract comes from the Bourbon Islands, off the coast of Madagascar, Africa. All Nighter- Coffee ice cream with chunks of cookie dough, crushed Oreo cookies, with a fudge swirl. Winner of the University of Delaware Ag Department best flavor contest.

Bacon- African Vanilla ice cream with actual pieces of bacon. The final recipe came from the Ice Cream School at Penn State University, after we made homemade bacon ice cream at the American Royal World Barbecue Championships in Kansas City and finished 5th out of 500! Made on the TV Food Network show Unwrapped during fall of 2008.

NEW 2014! Bacon de Leche- Dulce de Leche ice cream with tons of bacon, candied pecans, and a caramel swirl

Beer Ice Cream- Creamy cappuccino coffee ice cream with microbrewed Indian Brown Ale from Dogfish Head Brewery, Rehoboth Beach DE.

Ben Franklin's Tomato- African Vanilla ice cream with sugared egg yolks, castor (superfine) sugar, Heinie Hurtin' Hot Sauce and Campbell's tomato juice.

Better Than Sex- 2013 #1 Best Seller! Our special cake batter ice cream with Duncan Hine's Devils Food Cake Mix and African vanilla extract mixed in. Crunched up Heath Bars are added to the mixture and fudge is ribboned throughout. Won 3rd place ribbon at the 2009 Rehoboth Beach Chocolate Festival. 1st place at the May 2009 customer tasting party!

Black Cherry Vanilla- Vanilla ice cream stocked with big, plump, dark sweet cherries from Oregon.

Black Forest- Milk chocolate ice cream made with real raspberry puree. It has no sugar added and it's low carb.

Blood Orange Mango Ice Cream- African Vanilla with Blood Orange Juice, puree & flavoring, a pinch of salt, superfine sugar and mango flavoring. From a great gelato maker in the Chelsea Market in New York City.

Booger- Green colored African Vanilla ice cream with green colored caramel swirl and marshmallow bits. Finished 2nd at the 2010 tasting event.

Boston Cream Pie- Creamy French Vanilla ice cream with a giant fudge ripple. Finished 4th in the 2012 tasting event. Winner of the Woodside Farms Creamery best new flavor contest!

Breakfast in Bed- African Vanilla with pasteurized egg yolks, real maple syrup, and of course BACON!

Buttery Pecan Crunch- We wanted to make the best Butter Pecan ice cream in existence. This recipe came from an ice cream parlor in Denton, Texas, where the secret to making it better was that we had to follow the original recipe, which called for a "s**tload" of real butter. We also added many more pecans.

Butter Brickle Toffee-  Butter ice cream scattered with toffee pieces and almond chips.

Butterscotch Pudding- Butterscotch flavored Cake Batter ice cream with butterscotch swirl.

Buttery Salted Caramel- 2013 #3 Best Seller! Caramel praline pecan ice cream made with salted butter and sea salt. So irresistible, you'll want to stick your finger in it. Made with extra egg yolks. Won 2nd place in the National Championship at the NICRA show in Greenville, South Carolina.

Cake Batter- The trick to making the best Cake Batter ice cream is to mix real Betty Crocker Yellow Cake Mix with the raw ice cream before pasteurization. We do not add the eggs and we fully mix the product first, so there is not a hint of gritty taste.

Cake Batter Cookie Dough- 2012 #5 Best Seller! Sweet cake batter ice cream with authentic chunks of chocolate chip cookie dough.

Cake Batter with Reese's Cups- Cake batter ice cream with crushed Reese's cups & peanut butter swirl. 1st place at May 2011 tasting party!

Cappuccino Crunch- Cappuccino coffee ice cream mixed with butter brickle and crushed Heath Bars.

NEW 2014! Catching Fire- Orange colored African Vanilla ice cream with orange juice, mango & a strawberry swirl. A real scorpion will be placed on top of each cone.

Cereal Killer- Any flavor topped with Captain Crunch or Lucky Charms!

Cherry Coke- Sweet cream ice cream mixed with cherry coke syrup and Oregon black cherry halves.

Chocolate Brownie Batter- Milk chocolate ice cream mix is mixed with real brownie batter mix (no eggs are used.) Strong taste of actual brownie batter. Won the 3rd place ribbon at the 2008 Rehoboth Beach Chocolate Festival.

Chocolate Chocolate Thunder- The absolute best chocolate ice cream that we could make. Milk Chocolate ice cream blended with dark chocolate, white chocolate, and strong African vanilla extract. Won 2nd place ribbon at 2008 Rehoboth Beach Chocolate Festival.

Chocolate Covered Bacon- We use the famous bacon ice cream as the base and then fold in pieces of freshly pan-fried bacon that has been dipped in our enrobing chocolate & then frozen.

Chunky Pineapple- A vanilla ice cream base with tons of real pineapple chunks and a little real pineapple juice added.

Cinnamon Bun- Cake batter ice cream, flavored with cinnamon and brown sugar. With butterscotch swirled throughout.

Ciccolato Scuro (Bittersweet Chocolate)- Rich, black and serious bittersweet chocolate ice cream.

Coconut- Coconut flavored ice cream with shaved coconut added in and toasted coconut throughout.

Coconut Almond Chocolate Chip- Coconut ice cream with chopped almonds and miniature chocolate chips.

NEW 2014! Coffee Break- A very strong coffee/espresso ice cream with mini chocolate chips, pieces of cookie dough and brownie pieces.

Cola Vanilla- The famous African vanilla ice cream flavored with actual Coca Cola syrup. This recipe came from an ice cream parlor in New Orleans.

Cookie Dough Rock Slide- Cake batter ice cream, cookie dough, fudge, peanut butter.

Cookie Dough with Crushed Oreo Cookies- Exactly like it sounds, start with the best chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream and add smashed Oreos.

Cookie Monster- Blue colored cotton candy flavored ice cream, with crushed Oreo cookies and pieces of chocolate chip cookie dough. This recipe won 1st place nationally in the candy category, and 2nd at our 2009 customer tasting party.

Crack- Brown Sugah Vanilla ice cream with pasteurized egg yolk, butter, and sea salt. Finished FIRST at our May 2013 tasting party!

Crack These Big Nuts- Crack Ice Cream with a massive amount of assorted nuts mixed throughout: peanuts, cashews, almonds, and pecans.

Cranberry Cookie- Cookie Dough ice cream with cranberries, cranberry swirl, & white chocolate chips.

Delaware Peach- Peach flavored ice cream with lots of real, Delaware peaches added to it and the addition of nectarine puree.

Dirt- Milk chocolate ice cream with crushed Oreo cookies & gummi worms. And, if you wish, it is topped with a 'real' worm snack.

NEW 2014! Dirty Snowball- Creamy vanilla ice cream with peppermint flavoring, mini chocolate chips & Oreo cookies.

Dolly Madison Strawberry- This is the original recipe for ice cream as we know it today! From Aunt Sally Shedd in the early 1800s, made famous at a White House banquet. Sweet Cream ice cream made with juice from sugared strawberries. We made this historic flavor on the History TV Channel!

Espresso Chip- Very strong coffee/espresso flavored ice cream with lots of mini chocolate chips.

Extreme Vanilla Bean- The best vanilla ice cream ever made! Madagascar Bourbon Island vanilla extract is mixed with Indonesian, Tahitian, and French vanillas. Real vanilla bean flakes are also added to the mix.

Fluffer Nutter- Peanut butter ice cream with marshmallow creme running throughout.

Fruity Pebbles- African Vanilla ice cream with fruity pebbles cereal.

Ghost Pepper Ice Cream- Scorpion Sting ice cream with Mad Dog 357, Heartbreaking Dawns 1841, and Da' Bomb Ghost Pepper sauces added. Our good friends from the Two Fat Guys restaurant in Hockessin have also added in some fresh Ghost pepper mash. You WILL NOT be able to taste or buy this ice cream without first signing a waiver!

Gingerbread Cookie- Cake batter ice cream with tons of hand broken gingerbread men.

Going Nuts With Chocolate- Milk chocolate ice cream with lots of peanuts, almonds, cashews, and pecans.

Green Mint Chocolate Chip with Crushed Oreos and Cookie Dough- Just what it sounds like, a great mixture of all four flavors (made with spearmint extract)

Holy Purple Cow- Raspberry ice cream with blueberry ribboned throughout. White and milk chocolate chips are added in.

I Don't Give a Fork- African vanilla ice cream with brownie pieces, pretzel pieces, crushed Oreo cookies, cookie dough, and mini chocolate chips. A plastic fork is placed on top of every cone, to make it easier to eat!

Lavender- Vanilla bean ice cream with Lavender extract and the actual purple Lavender flower added, as well as a touch of orange blossom honey.

Lemon Chiffon with Red Bull- Tart lemon chiffon ice cream mixed with Red Bull energy drink. AKA: Energy.

Lemon Chiffon- Tart lemon chiffon ice cream with marshmallow creme.

Lemon Sorbet- Fantastic for smoothies and dairy free.

NEW 2014! Lick Me, I'm Delicious- Milk chocolate ice cream with nougat, chocolate caramel, sea salt, orange blossom honey, & cocoa nibs.

Looks Like Viagra- Orange Pineapple ice cream that happens to be colored blue. A Midwestern ice cream parlor favorite. AKA: Viagra, Cialis, Blue Moon.

Lucky Charms- African vanilla with tons of the little freeze dried marshmallows made famous in Lucky Charms cereal.

Mango Sorbet- Completely dairy free, mango fruit flavored (great for smoothies!)

Mayan Chocolate Cinnamon- Milk chocolate ice cream infused with real cinnamon and charged with a wee bit of Cayenne pepper.

NEW 2014! Menage a Trois- Peanut butter ice cream with semi-large pieces of strawberries & a marshmallow swirl. Strawberry marshmallow fluff will be put on top of the cone.

NEW 2014! Milk Chocolate Crack- Milk chocolate ice cream with Turbinado brown sugar, butter, sea salt & pasteurized egg yolks.

Minty Python- Milk chocolate ice cream with peppermint flavoring, mixed with broken up York peppermint patties and mini chocolate chips. Each cone is topped with a real York Peppermint Patty.

Motor Oil- Smooth coffee ice cream with fudge ripple and caramel ripple, colored green.

Mountain Dew- African vanilla mixed with Mountain Dew syrup, orange juice, and crushed pineapple.

My Milkshake Brings All the Boys to the Store- Blue Ribbon Milk Chocolate ice cream with Madagascar vanilla extract. A ribbon of milk chocolate runs throughout.

Natural Oreo Cookie- When we mix the actual Oreos into the ice cream in the beginning, we get a dull, gray coloring when finished.

Nutella- African Vanilla ice cream mixed with Nutella.

Nutty Cake Batter- Cake batter ice cream mixed with lots of peanuts, cashews, almonds, & pecans.

Ooey Gooey- Cake batter with crushed Oreo cookies and swirled with caramel and chocolate fudge. First place at the 2010 tasting event!

Oreo Cookie Cake Batter- Cake batter ice cream with crushed Oreo cookies and chocolate sprinkles.

Peach Melba- Extreme vanilla bean and Peach ice cream with peaches and a raspberry ribbon.

Peanut Butter and Jelly- Peanut Butter ice cream with raspberry ribboned throughout.

NEW 2014! Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Fudge- Peanut butter ice cream with mini chocolate chips and a ribbon of chocolate fudge.

Peanut Butter Oreo Cookie- Creamy peanut butter ice cream with lots of crushed Oreo cookies. Second place at the 2012 customer tasting party!

Peanut Butter with Caramel Brownies- Creamy Skippy peanut butter ice cream, waves of caramel ripple, and chunks of brownies. Finished 3rd at the 2010 tasting event.

Peppermint Brownie- Pink Mint Chocolate Chip ice cream with brownie pieces, white chocolate chips, and a chocolate fudge swirl.

Pink Mint Chip- Made with real peppermint extract, which is why the mint flavor is so intense. The dark, sweet chocolate chips just make it so much better.

Pistachio Cardamom Honey- African vanilla with cardamom spice (from India) with a touch of Orange Blossom honey added as well as a small amount of Pistachio flavoring.

Pop Rocks- Any flavor of ice cream with authentic Pop Rocks layered over the top. It really does pop in your mouth! Available Pop Rocks flavors include Strawberry, Watermelon, and (occasionally) Bubblegum.

Pumpkin Pecan- Pumpkin ice cream made with pumpkin pie filling and mixed with pecan pieces.

Raspberry Sorbet- Dairy free, so that customers that are lactose intolerant will love it. A very rich raspberry flavor and dark raspberry color.

Raspberry Chocolate Thunder- Chocolate Chocolate Thunder with raspberry rippled throughout. Winner 2009 Rehoboth Beach Chocolate Festival.

Rocky Peppermint Road- Milk chocolate ice cream with miniature marshmallows and nuts. The peppermint comes from crushed candy canes. Won first place ribbon at the 2008 Rehoboth Beach Chocolate Festival, and 2009 2nd place ribbon.

NEW 2014! Sangria- A very intense ice cream / Italian Sorbetto recipe with a fruity wine flavor that melts in your mouth.

Samoa- Coconut flavored Milk Chocolate ice cream with flakes of coconut and a heavy fudge and caramel ripple. Our attempt to match the famous Girl Scout Cookie.

Serious Chocolate Addiction- Chocolate Chocolate Thunder ice cream with chocolate flakes added and fudge rippled throughout.

Sour Cherry- Vanilla with sour cherry flavoring, black cherry halves, mini chocolate raspberry truffle cups, and lemon juice.

Spinach Salad- African vanilla ice cream with finely ground up fresh spinach folded in. A recipe from Baltimore. AKA: Popeye's favorite.

Strawberry Oreo- Smooth strawberry ice cream with tons of sliced strawberries and crushed authentic Oreo cookies.

Stifler's Mom- Brown Sugah Vanilla ice cream with Cayenne pepper powder, candied pecans, and a caramel ribbon.

Sweet Corn- We use a sweet cream base and add real sweet, sugary corn to it.

Tea with Honey & Lemon Ice Cream- African Vanilla ice cream made with brewed tea, orange blosson honey, and lemon.

The Fig's Up- African vanilla with fig preserves, natural orange blossom honey, cinnamon, and small pieces of dates.

Third Trimester- Peanut butter ice cream with bananas and chocolate swirl.

This Ish is Off the Hook!- Crack ice cream with mini chocolate chips, brownie pieces, pecans, crushed Oreo cookies, and caramel swirl.

Thunder and Lightning- Chocolate Chocolate Thunder with thick, white marshmallow ribbons running throughout.

Traffic Jam- Strawberry and African vanilla with peaches, strawberry swirl, cranberries, and black cherries.

Turtle Candy- Rich milk chocolate with caramel swirl and toasted pecans.

White Lightning- White chocolate ice cream with ribbons of marshmallow.

White Wine- African Vanilla ice cream with Nassau Valley's Broadkiln White Wine, castor (superfine) sugar, orange juice and lemon juice.

Zombie- Blue Raspberry ice cream with strawberry (bloody) swirl, cut up gummi fingers and mini marshmallows. Each cone is topped with a gummi/marshmallow eyeball! Third place at the May 2012 customer tasting party!